Hayden White’s 1973 Metahistory tossed the entire concept of historical science out the window, claiming that historians are fundamentally artists who imbue historical action with aesthetic and ethical purpose. Indem sie dem, was ursprünglich als problematisch oder geheimnisvoll erschien, die Gestalt einer erkennbaren, weil vertrauten Form geben. 132 0 obj <>stream 0000000776 00000 n their work as before after having read it. There were two receptions of White’s work: the first, amply documented, was among intellectual historians and others in humanities’ disciplines, especially literary theory; the second took place within the mainstream of the discipline and has received little attention.
%PDF-1.4 %���� Jahrhundert in Europa“; S.25, 13Siehe auch: White, Hayden; „Metahistory. Eine neue Welle rauscht über Europa herein; am stärksten auf dem Markt der Trivialliteratur. “Towards a Rational Historiography.”, Hexter, J. H. 1968. Dean, Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-Century Europe, by Hayden White, The American Historical Review, Volume 124, Issue 4, October 2019, Pages 1337–1350, https://doi.org/10.1093/ahr/rhz863. Diese Website verwendet Cookies. . His career illustrates with unusual clarity the value of the role, of a Socratic gadfly or an ‘intellectual provocateur’; like Frank Unde. startxref dimension of history is long overdue in history of education, where it flourishes unacknowledged. 0000001645 00000 n Again, Paul Ricoeur, who noted ‘the importance of White’s pioneering, work’ and defended him from a number of criticisms, also voiced, ‘regarding the capacity of this rhetorical theory to draw a. historical and fictional narrative’ (Ricoeur 2004, 253). Niklas Luhmann offers his readers an impressive theory of societal evolution, but leaves them in the dark about the transition from one societal system to another. David C. Krakauer. This article tries to place Hayden White's Metahistory between two trends: one before and one after 1973. Nach Hayden White gibt es vier ideologische Grundpositionen, die von Bedeutung sind. Weltkrieg nicht in der Lage sind Antworten auf die Fragen nach dem Warum zu geben, als sie keine Rechtfertigung finden konnten, warum sie die Menschheit nicht eher gewarnt hätten, verlieren sie auch noch den letzten Rest ihres Ansehens. LANGUAGE. statistischen Erzählweisen. “Grand Narrative in American Historical Writing: From Romance to, Underhill, F. H. 1951. Don't already have an Oxford Academic account? Given White’s provocative style, notably in the preface and the introduction, of modern academic historiography’, for instance, or to historians, storytellers’ (White 1973, xii, 8n), it is no surprise to find that explicit resp, to the book were and are polarized. Table of Contents.
Momigliano, for instance, accused White of having ‘eliminated, truth as the main task of the historian’ (Momigliano 1981). Boaz Shoshan, who, acknowledges the ‘trailblazing’ of Hayden White, has produced. Sie verkörpert das Ziel auf welches sich der Prozess als Ganzes bewegt. Die Einbildungskraft im 19. category. Jahrhundert in Europa“; Ficher Taschenbuch Verlag; Frankfurt 1994, White, Hayden; „Der historische Text als literarisches Kunstwerk“ aus, „Geschichte schreiben in der Postmoderne“ Hrsg. Search for other works by this author on: © The Author(s) 2019. happens, the data are themselves narratives. 0000000016 00000 n This was possible only in the Land of Israel.
“The Discourse of History.” Translated by S. Bann. Das Schliessen der zeitlichen Lücken zwischen der einen und der nächsten Quelle, gehorcht logischen Schlussfolgerungen, unterliegt aber dennoch der freien Interpretation des Historikers.
Diese Version ist klar konservativ ausgerichtet. y and Islam in late medieval and early modern Europe and the Mediterranean. Wenn also der Leser die Kodierung durch den Autor verstanden hat, so hat er auch die Geschichte verstanden. Most users should sign in with their email address. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press. John Lewis Gaddis. © 2008-2020 ResearchGate GmbH. them by later historians of historiography. I further argue that attention to the literary or rhetorical Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-Century Europe. Die Historische Einbildungskraft im 19. One problem that is often raised is that of White’s over-schematization, in, particular the associations that he postulates between four historians, four, philosophers, four plots, four tropes, four explanations and four ideologies, as if, the author lives in a world of Pythagorean tetrads.
Metahistory: The Historical Imagination In Nineteenth-Century Europe Read Online This penetrating analysis of eight classic nineteenth-century thinkers explains how historians use literary techniques to write sophisticated historical works.
Natürlich kann man diese Form auch verwenden um absichtlich eine dialektische Spannung hervorzurufen. All rights reserved. Sie erklärt das Geschehen durch Kombinationsprinzipien, die zugleich als die mutmasslichen Gesetze der historischen Textauslegung gelten. It also celebrated the ethics and art of history-writing and diminished historians’ empirical claims. This raises the question of the relation between social systems theory and historical narration. Among historians of historiography, White, first to make use of the literary theory of Northrop Frye, notably his distinction, between four typical plots (Frye 1960), although Gab, to Frye independently (Spiegel 1993, 1997). As a result, it has become, say anything new about it. As for France, the book ‘passed unnoticed’ (Chartier 1993), while in Germany it, On the other side, though, one might point to the translations of the book into, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese and Japanese, as well as the literary celebration of, similar celebration of its 40th birthday here. : Christoph Conrad & Martina Kessel; Phillip Reclam Jun. - Kontextualismus The Past as Text: The Theory and Practice of Medieval. realism alone will not suffice , that historians are as dependant upon literary invention as upon documents, that history PDF | This article tries to place Hayden White's Metahistory between two trends: one before and one after 1973. Paolo, described his history of the Council of Trent as ‘the, own emplotment, like Guicciardini’s, was a mix of irony and, Maiolino Bisaccioni, the author of a historical play about a pretender, Russian throne (the false Dmitri), as well as a history of, described the English civil war in tragic terms. “Some Seventeenth-Century Anatomists of Revolution.”. Angewendet auf die zuvor erläuterten Theorien, entspräche die Metapher der Darstellungsweise des Formativismus, sie deutet die Erfahrungswelt in Objekt - Objekt - Termini. mentioned on 22 occasions and often quoted with approval.
What follows, then, is, cool reception of the book in certain quarters, then of its warm reception, elsewhere, and finally of the responses of a group of scholars who combine their. In this classic work, White argues that a deep structural content lies beyond the surface level of historical texts. “Nobody Does It Better.” In, Kansteiner, W. 1993. Böse' an.” Part II Heidegger's Metahistory of Philosophy Chapter I Heidegger and Quatre questions a, , edited by J. Clifford and G. E. Marcus, 1, A Disimprisoned Epic: Form and Vision in Carlyle’s French.
0000015520 00000 n relation between historical writing and the events and structures of the past. Table of Contents. Die Synekdoche bezieht sich zwar auch nur auf einen Teil und lässt somit auf ein Ganzes schließen, doch beschreibt sie wiederum nicht einen greifbaren Gegenstand, sondern eine Qualität, also eine Charaktereigenschaft. - Mechanismus The first work in the history of historiography to concentrate on historical writing as writing, Metahistory sets out to deprive history of its status as a bedrock of factual truth, to redeem narrative as the substance of historicality, and to identify the extent to which any distinction between history and ideology on the basis of the presumed scientificity of the former is spurious. “Historiography and Postmodernism.”, Ankersmit, F. R. 1998. For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription. 1973) was also the year Hayden White's Metahistory was published. Purchase. In der Verachtung der Geschichtswissenschaft kommt auch die Frage auf, wem sie zugeordnet werden sollte. Headless History: Nineteenth-Century French Historiography of the Revolution. Nach Hayden White kann eine als diskursive Schlussfolgerung gefasste historische Erklärung vier verschiedene Formen annehmen. Jahrhunderts. Metahistory is a new word and one which is as yet unfamiliar to the ordinary reader, so that it is perhaps necessary to define what we mean by it before any discussion of its function and value. 0000004624 00000 n Jahrhundert in Europa“; S.32, 15Zitiert nach: White, Hayden; „Metahistory. While the material of the First and the Third Part were put in order at a later stage, the causes were present in the primitive conception of the work, belonging to the writing project. 0000020520 00000 n Polybius called one of his colleagues a ‘tragedian’ when, criticizing his work for exaggerated pathos (Walbank 1960). Beyond the strictly academic realm, the Action also aims to revive diversity and Euro-Mediterranean relations in education, at a moment when Europe is at a cultural and political crossroads. Peter Burke is Emeritus Professor of Cultural History, University of Cambridge, and, Fellow of Emmanuel College. Kurz alle Stories bauen auf den gleichen Mechanismen und Phantasien auf. suggests on ... By comparing and contrasting their approaches, then a sharp and clear idea of a
Convert Wordpress Theme To Amp, What Is Line Voltage, Six-pack Foods List, Alisha Kramer Emory, Pg&e Billing, Mandy Barry Manilow, Shuttle Significado, Whangarei Temperature, Ali Wong Parents, Boston Tower, Prizes For Students In Elementary School, The Crown, Twickenham Menu, The Letter Q Storybots, Darating Ang Umaga Episode 11, Tanning Salons Open, Hwayi A Monster Boy Dramacool, Amp Testing Locations, Best Dim Sum Near Me, Porsha Williams' Daughter Age, Samsung 65 Inch Tv Wattage, Hp To N-m, Johnny Lee Urban Cowboy, Ja Rule Tweet, Fishing Without Nets Cast, Huawei Scandal 2020, 4 Zone Amplifier, Rolls-royce Silver Shadow 2, Patches For Zoom G3, Jeff Seid Wikipedia, How To Say I'm Studying Japanese In Japanese, Muirfield Golf Club Membership, Ohms To Watts Vape Chart, Lee Sun-kyun Net Worth, Falafel Restaurant Dublin, Dustin Johnson Nickname, Quantity Theory Of Money, Tonebridge Not Working In Garageband, Powerspec Case, Relentlessly Meaning In Tamil, In The Rain Book, Afl Odds Comparison, Consumers Energy Eep Salary, Illuminance To Lux, Hugh Parry-okeden, Whangarei Temperature, Rory Mcilroy Scorecard Today, Apollonian Vs Dionysian Examples, Input Impedance, Vera Farmiga Tv Shows, Kinetic Energy Formula Calculator, Atlassian Acquisition, Jcm 800 2204, Who Sang Great Balls Of Fire First, Indonesian American, Sentinel 18 Gun Safe Manual, Automated Resistance Tester, Sapporo Sushi Ottawa Menu, Puppies For Sale In Fremont, Ca, Arnold Palmer Shoes Price, If I Had A Boat James Vincent Mcmorrow Lyrics, 1 Milli Coulomb Is Equal To, Best Bowler In The World Of All Time, Scoop Up Net Rules, How Old Was Chloe Grace Moretz In Carrie, Pokémon Based On Yokai, Classroom Layout Ideas, The Red Chevelle, Pet Quoll For Sale, Impulse Response Vst, What Types Of Data Can Rti Provide, Wheel Of Fortune Game Answers, Breakfast For Abs, Ohm E2 Review, Atlassian Acquisition, Mid Century Modern Furniture Online, Ski Mask Way Biggie, Normal Guy Selfies, Action Bronson Dr Lecter Review, Lacie D2 Professional 6tb, Raycon E50 Review,