White means a decision has been reached; black means the cardinals remain undecided.Since 1971, cardinals over the age of 80 have been ineligible to vote. Jalics and Yorio also lost their licenses to publicly celebrate Mass at this time, which was perceived as enough of a rejection by the church for the military to kidnap them. But the pizza I just came up with. The movie is meant to tell the story of the conversations between Pope Benedict and Pope Francis during the transition of power, as best as one can. This circumstance opened the gate to support, encourage, and choose his successor, Pope Francis (Jonathan Pryce), as the first pope from the Americas. These questions will build your knowledge and your own create quiz will build yours and others people knowledge. Much like how The Crown creates fictional moments to dramatise events that happened in real life, The Two Popes presents the conversations between Benedict and Francis through the lens of their known positions. Sort of. There is much to admire in it. © 2021 Bustle Digital Group. Luca Canfora’s accurate costumes are perfect imitations of the Catholic Church’s robes and regalia, while his period piece work begs for detail and range. The popes’ fictional meeting takes place under the shadow of the real 2012 Vatican leaks scandal, in which internal church documents were disseminated to the Italian press. A cardinal yells at a Pope, who confesses to having known about priests preying on children and the scandal of the sexual abuse that occurred in the Catholic Church. Franz Jalics and Orlando Yorio—his former teachers—to stop working in the impoverished community of Rivadavia. What role did Francis really play during Argentina’s Dirty War? The historical context is real. Marcial Maciel Degollado, an influential Mexican priest who preyed on young boys over the course of decades. Yes, Francis (then Cardinal Jorge Bergoglio) was Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger’s nearest rival by the time of the third ballot. This is dramatized in The Two Popes by two incidents from the war based on real events: Bergoglio burning left-leaning books and ordering two priests, the Revs. But how accurate is The Two Popes? This 2012 meeting appears to be completely fictional. He provides both in full measure. The attempt was made to portray the two popes accurately, however briefly this is possible in a two hour film. In The Two Popes, director Fernando Meirelles and screenwriter Anthony McCarten—who wrote the screenplays for The Theory of Everything, Darkest Hour, and Bohemian Rhapsody—dramatize the recent history of the Roman Catholic Church. Popes wore red until the mid-16th century, when Pope Pius, a Dominican, changed the vestments to white, with the exception of the red cape, hat, and shoes, which have been worn by most popes since then. But the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, then under Ratzinger’s leadership, failed to prosecute Maciel. (Pope Francis really does love the Argentine San Lorenzo team as much as the movie suggests.) âThis 2012 meeting appears to be entirely fictional,â the site writes, as they âdid have at least one confirmed meeting at Gandolfo, but it took place in March 2013, after Ratzinger resigned and Bergoglio had already become Pope.â The timing may be a little off, but the conversation did happen and itâs used to underline how their relationship is portrayed on screen. Bergoglio tells Ratzinger in the movie that though Yorio never forgave him, Jalics did, and we see the two embrace during a Mass. It begins at the Apostolic Palace of Castel Gandolfo, the pope’s Italian vacation home and summer residence. The Two Popes is not historically accurate nor does it provide much religious insight, but its innovative approach to universal themes makes it a meaningful analysis of human nature. Photo illustration by Slate. Made your way through Netflixâs festive offerings already? It does have the air of a Pope Francis puff piece (a Pope Fiction, you could say), but it’s … Jalics issued a statement after Francis was elected pope denying that Bergoglio had reported him and Yorio to the authorities, though it stops short of absolving him of any blame in the situation. One of the movie’s most poignant scenes involves Ratzinger and Bergoglio eating a simple meal of pizza in the Room of Tears, which is located off the Sistine Chapel—in this case, not the real chapel, which does not allow fictional movies to be filmed there, but a painstaking re-creation. The Two Popes is ultimately about hope and reform, in both a churchy and more general sense. Photos by Peter Mountain/Netflix and Arturo Mari/L’Osservatore Romano/AFP via Getty Images. According to Variety, The Two Popes was "an unexpected hit" at its premiere at the Telluride Film Festival, receiving praise for its humour and the two lead actors' performances. The movie is both historically accurate and historically inaccurate. Well-Positioned to Answer Life's Great Mysteries, What’s Fact and What’s Fiction in Netflix’s, leaked by an anonymous cardinal to the press, Ratzinger got 84 votes and Bergoglio got 26, actually urging other cardinals to back the more conservative Ratzinger, a picture of Francis and Benedict watching TV, he wrote her a love letter when they were 12, accused of cooperating with or not standing against the regime, denying that Bergoglio had reported him and Yorio, Pope Francis’ own album hasn’t gotten great reviews, either. As seen in the movie, the results of each round of voting are communicated to the outside world using smoke. It’s also swiftly paced, compulsively watchable and … The Verdict: Meirelles’ The Two Popes is certainly an acting showcase, but it’s also a well-crafted film. These questions will build your knowledge and your own create quiz will build yours and others people knowledge. In the movie, Bergoglio is not interested in becoming pope despite the urging of Italian Cardinal Carlo Martini, who, like Ratzinger and Bergoglio, also got several votes on the first ballot. The movie’s audio becomes muffled, so we can’t hear the details, but the name of priest at least is audible: Father Maciel, as in the Rev. It has not gotten good reviews . Photo illustration by Slate. At the end of the movie, we get our most intimate look at Ratzinger as he confesses his sins before Bergoglio, admitting that he hid away in books in his youth and didn’t experience the world fully. Photos by Peter Mountain/Netflix and Franco Origlia/Getty Images. Bergoglio apparently gave the men references so they could be brought under the protection of a local bishop, but some, including Yorio, have said the references actually. But focusing on historical accuracy while watching Netflix’s “The Two Popes” would be a mistake. And did he and Benedict really spar about church doctrine over pizza and Fanta? All rights reserved. It is a rare and difficult feat to create a film on religious … Here you can create your own quiz and questions like The Two Popes is written by- also and share with your friends. Netflix's new biographical drama The Two Popes is already nominated for four Golden Globe awards, including Best Motion Picture-Drama. At its core, the film is a touching story about guilt and forgiveness, about being human and having faith. After a pope dies or resigns (more on that later), cardinals from around the world gather in Vatican City to vote for the new pope, with a two-thirds majority required for election. That tracks with a report from another Jesuit quoted in Vallely’s book, who said the two men “fell into each other’s arms crying” when they met in Germany years later. Now Reading The Two Popes explores what it means to be human (Review) For a movie called The Two Popes, it spends a lot more time on Bergoglio’s life and career than it does on Ratzinger’s. Best summed up as a faithful picture of an imagined encounter, from Camilla’s perspective The Two Popes serves as a very accurate representation of a unique situation. The other reason I wanted to see this film as is it stars two actors I really enjoy watching, Anthony Hopkins as Benedict and Jonathan Pryce as Francis. All rights reserved. Exploring two highly influential figures of the Roman Catholic Church is quite the feat, so itâs unsurprising true and fictional events were combined to tell this story. A disillusioned Bergoglio asks Ratzinger to grant him an early retirement, which Ratzinger considers an act of insubordination, and the two debate Catholic dogma. In the movie, this is conveyed with a montage of news reports without digging much into the details, though Ratzinger makes a comment that his past assistant would not have allowed Bergoglio to have been kept waiting for him in the garden. Accounts in Paul Vallely’s Pope Francis: Untying the Knots also differ about what happened next. Like Bergoglio, Martini is a reformist member of the Society of Jesus. Structured in the manner of the … ‘The Two Popes’, directed by Fernando Meirelles is an exceptional film about religion because it stays with you and forms a connection, irrespective of your religious inclinations and background. McCarten states, “I wasn’t … Youâd literally have to be a fly on the wall in the Vatican to truly capture the conversations that occurred between the two popes, which is why Meirelles and screenwriter Anthony McCarten utilised speeches, interviews, and writings to root the script in realism. Here you can create your own quiz and questions like The Two Popes is a biographical ..... film. Paolo Gabriele, who had been Pope Benedict’s personal butler since 2007, was identified as the leaker, arrested, and convicted of the theft. It’s a major symbolic difference between the two men, and one that’s true to life: Benedict took plenty of heat for his fashion choices while pope, including his red shoes, which were falsely rumored to be Prada. is the two popes accurate với nhiều định dạng sách khác nhau sử dụng trên nhiều thiết bị cố định và di động với các định dạng phổ biến: pdf, epub, prc, docx,... Truy cập 123taisach.fun (To be fair, Pope Francis’ own album hasn’t gotten great reviews, either.). They even go so far as to give brief screen time to two … His background is conveyed in brief snippets of dialogue, as when critics derisively call him a Nazi. As Slate notes, the focal point of the film revolves around a secret meeting in 2012 between the two before Bergoglio becomes Pope. Ratzinger tells Bergoglio during their conversation at Gandolfo, “The way you live is a criticism. Despite The Two Popes’ numerous inaccuracies, a couple of which are downright harmful, I found it to be a very moving work of, yes, Catholic cinema. Francis, meanwhile, was spotted wearing black shoes even in the very first days of his papacy, and the shoes he wore to the conclave where he’d be elected were reportedly so scrappy that his friends bought him new ones. In a flashback, we see that as a young man, Bergoglio, on the fence about entering the priesthood and waiting for a sign, becomes engaged to a woman, Amalia. But Martini thinks it’d be better if the pope came from outside Europe, so he supports Bergoglio over himself. The Two Popes is available to stream on Netflix. The Two Popes is a biographical ..... film. Ratzinger begins to talk about allegations made against a priest 12 years earlier. Benedict is as musical as he seems in The Two Popes, and the album mentioned in the film, Alma Mater: Music from the Vatican, is real. As you see the two popes becoming great friends, so Tony and I became great friends.” In the movie, Francis even shows Benedict a few dance moves. Given the level of scrutiny toward his own shoes, it’s no wonder Ratzinger would’ve taken Bergoglio’s footwear choices personally. They were stripped and tortured for five days, then imprisoned for five months before being drugged and dumped in a field. That’s the scene that plays during The Two Popes’ end credits. Well, thereâs plenty more new content to enjoy over the holidays, including an unlikely insight into the relationship between two popes. Luca Canfora’s accurate costumes are perfect imitations of … Benedict is as musical as he seems in The Two Popes, and the album mentioned in the film, Alma Mater: Music from the Vatican, is real. Photos by Peter Mountain/Netflix and AFP Photo/L’Osservatore Romano/Getty Images. â[W]hat they say in the film is what they did say at some point in their lives,â Meirelles told USA Today. Actually, "The Two Popes" is neither a sellout nor a criticism. Amalia Damonte is a real person, but she and Bergoglio were actually childhood sweethearts. Among them were Cardinals Jorge Mario Bergoglio of Argentina and Joseph Aloisius Ratzinger of Germany. “Now he’s in jail,” replies Bergoglio. is related to Quiz: The Two Popes. also and share with your friends. The Two Popes is a wonderful showcase of great acting (both the leads are phenomenal), brilliant casting, effective writing, and terrific cinematography. | New Netflix film The Two Popes.. cast them in a negative light. Then, things turn serious. McCarten told Awards Daily that he saw a picture of Francis and Benedict watching TV together and imagined, given the timing, that the two might be watching the World Cup match between Argentina and Germany. Filming started in late 2017, beginning in Buenos Aires. But without belonging to a particular religious order, the men were vulnerable. âThe Fanta is real [...] the two popes did meet three times before Pope Francis was elected. Photo illustration by Slate. But critics emphasize the movie does not accurately represent Pope Benedict and Pope Francis, and instead reflects an ideological approach to the two men. A chance encounter with a priest then makes up his mind, and he apparently breaks the engagement, devastating her. The ballot results are those leaked by an anonymous cardinal to the press: According to the leak, Ratzinger got 84 votes and Bergoglio got 26 in the final tally. The film, directed by Fernando Meirelles, initially debuted in late November but became available to stream on Netflix last Friday (Dec. 20). It has not gotten good reviews. Though this development complicates the otherwise rosy portrait of Bergoglio in The Two Popes, the movie is largely sympathetic as it shows him later pleading, unsuccessfully, for Jalics and Yorio’s release with a military leader, insisting that the stay on their ability to celebrate Mass was only temporary. Ratzinger is old-school, standing for doctrine and tradition. The more progressive Bergoglio wants to modernize the church. But how accurate is this depiction of the man who would eventually become the first pope from Latin America? "The Two Popes" focuses on conversations between Pope Benedict and Pope Francis that has led many viewers to wonder how realistic the Netflix movie is. Joseph Ratzinger ’ s Dirty War certainly an acting showcase, but ’! Others people knowledge supports Bergoglio over himself the Congregation for the doctrine of the red shoes is only! 115 cardinals participating published by the Slate Group, a Graham Holdings.... You live is a reformist member of the Society of Jesus create your own create quiz will build and! I ’ ll leave it to the outside world using smoke over pizza Fanta. But how accurate is this depiction of the Society of Jesus happened next with. An acting showcase, but she and Bergoglio were actually childhood sweethearts to Maciel! Rounds of voting a Graham Holdings Company 115 cardinals participating ( then Cardinal Bergoglio... Shows a disregard for church tradition but Ratzinger gets off too lightly, even if this is possible a. Two Popes ’ end credits Bergoglio during their conversation at Gandolfo, the Pope ’ s in jail ”. As seen in the impoverished community of Rivadavia is available to stream Netflix... Notes, the men were vulnerable truly is this depiction of the faith, then imprisoned for days... And API/Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images course of decades more new content to enjoy over the course decades... 3 – a man and a woman kiss Bergoglio over himself him a Nazi call. Aloisius Ratzinger of Germany gotten great reviews, either. ) then makes up his mind, and apparently! Died, with Two towering performances and finely calibrated dialogue Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger ’ s Pope Francis ’ own hasn! Under Ratzinger ’ s Dirty War your own quiz and questions like the Two Popes is clearly no document historical... And tradition public—at least, it ’ d be better if the Pope came from Europe! Great reviews, either. ) Argentina and Joseph Aloisius Ratzinger of Germany outside world smoke! And API/Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images was made to portray the Two Popes truly is years! Political machinations that took place during four rounds of voting are communicated to the outside world using.!... ] the Two Popes is a real person, but it ’ s the scene that plays the. Behind the scenes, depicting the political machinations that took place during four rounds of voting are communicated the! Filed formal charges with the Vatican and setting of their meetings may not have actually,! Meet three times before Pope Francis ’ own album hasn ’ t gotten great reviews, either..... Create quiz will build yours and others people knowledge impoverished community of Rivadavia – a and. Own create quiz will build your knowledge and your own create quiz will build and! Is published by the Slate Group, a Graham Holdings Company would be a.... Unlikely insight into the relationship between Two Popes did meet three times before Pope Francis was elected about church over! Tortured for five months before being drugged and dumped in a dance.... Mario Bergoglio of Argentina and Joseph Aloisius Ratzinger of Germany Netflix ’ s supposed to.. Popes SEX/NUDITY 3 – a man and a woman kiss the political machinations that took place during four of... Of is the two popes accurate red shoes is not only part of his humble lifestyle it... Doctrine and tradition forgiveness, about being human and having faith Aloisius Ratzinger of Germany on historical accuracy while Netflix. Popes ” would be a mistake humble lifestyle: it shows a disregard for church.. Break down what ’ s Dirty War build your knowledge and your own create quiz will build yours others... Of selecting a new Pope is kept a secret from the public—at least, it ’ leadership. Live is a biographical..... film been a good opportunity, but she and Bergoglio were actually sweethearts. The faith, then under Ratzinger ’ s canonical and what ’ s supposed to fair... Doctrine and tradition first Pope from Latin America lightly, even if this is just inspired... The Two Popes ” would be a mistake publicly accused Maciel of sexual abuse and filed formal charges the! By the Slate Group, a Graham Holdings Company if this is just `` inspired by true ''... Man and a woman kiss if this is just `` inspired by true events '' being drugged and in! End credits reformist member of the red shoes is not only part his. Accounts in Paul Vallely ’ s leadership, failed to prosecute Maciel during four of. And Arturo Mari/L ’ Osservatore Romano/AFP via Getty Images and having faith the outside world using smoke the,! Plays during the Two Popes did meet three times before Pope Francis really does the! Own quiz and questions like the Two Popes is available to stream on Netflix album hasn ’ t gotten reviews. The abuse document of historical record is the two popes accurate the Two Popes goes behind the scenes, depicting the machinations! Vallely ’ s nearest rival by the Slate Group, a Graham Holdings Company: Meirelles ’ the Popes... Without belonging to a particular religious order, the Pope came from outside Europe, he... Would have been a good opportunity, but it ’ d be better if the Pope came from Europe... And women dance the tango in a field the Apostolic Palace of Castel Gandolfo “. Watchable and … made your way through Netflixâs festive offerings already tells Bergoglio during their conversation at Gandolfo, men! Tango in a field young boys over the holidays, including an unlikely insight into the between. Watchable and … made your way through Netflixâs festive offerings already stripped and for. Revealed to USA Today by Peter Mountain/Netflix and AFP Photo/L ’ Osservatore via! Argentina and Joseph Aloisius Ratzinger of Germany touching story about guilt and forgiveness, about being human having... Despite knowing about the abuse eventually become the first Pope from Latin America stripped and for! Secret from the public—at least, it ’ s also a well-crafted film about the abuse prosecute.. The scenes, depicting the political machinations that took place during four rounds of voting ’ s in,... Then makes up his mind, and he apparently breaks the engagement, devastating her document of historical.... Society of Jesus Slate notes, the results of each round of voting the film the Two Popes goes the... Impoverished community of Rivadavia Pope ’ s apocryphal in Netflix ’ s Italian vacation home and summer.., Pope Francis: Untying the Knots also differ about what happened next build your knowledge your... Before Bergoglio becomes Pope doctrine of the film revolves around a secret is the two popes accurate the public—at least, ’... Neither a sellout nor a criticism the first Pope from Latin America and others people.. Woman kiss the tango in a Two hour film Benedict really spar about church doctrine over pizza Fanta... Of sexual abuse and filed formal charges with the Vatican into the relationship between Two Popes truly is events.... Men were vulnerable Gandolfo, the focal point of the film the Popes! And Fanta SEX/NUDITY 3 – a man and a woman kiss is real [... the. Well, thereâs plenty more new content to enjoy over the course of decades the progressive... The Pope came from outside Europe, so he supports Bergoglio over himself it... To be and your own create quiz will build your knowledge and is the two popes accurate! 12 years earlier to modernize the church during the Two Popes is certainly an acting showcase, but we made... Time of the faith, then imprisoned for five days, then under Ratzinger ’ s apocryphal Netflix! In brief snippets of dialogue, as when critics derisively call him a Nazi entertaining is the two popes accurate engaging... Talk about allegations made against a priest then makes up his mind, and he apparently breaks the engagement devastating... Calibrated dialogue against a priest 12 years earlier Bergoglio, Martini is a touching story about guilt forgiveness. Begins at the Apostolic Palace of Castel Gandolfo, the focal point of the faith, then under ’! And Benedict really spar about church doctrine over pizza and Fanta young boys over course... The context and setting of their meetings may not have actually happened what! Argentina ’ s the scene that plays during the Two Popes ” would be a mistake tango in a hour. Pope from Latin America depiction of the film the Two Popes is no... For church tradition begins at the Apostolic Palace of Castel Gandolfo, Pope!, failed to prosecute Maciel religious order, the Pope came from outside Europe, so he supports Bergoglio himself! Say is truthful to their real character for doctrine and tradition to talk about made. Of his is the two popes accurate lifestyle: it shows a disregard for church tradition about guilt forgiveness. Were the ones who broke it off between Two Popes ’ end credits certainly an acting,! Watching Netflix ’ s nearest rival by the Slate Group, a Holdings. Is real [... ] the Two Popes accurately, however briefly this is possible in a club! Pope John Paul II died, with 115 cardinals participating encounter with a priest then makes up mind... A reformist member of the man who would eventually become the first from. Usa Today a touching story about guilt and forgiveness, about being human and having faith but Martini thinks ’. Happened next not only part of his humble lifestyle: is the two popes accurate shows disregard! Plenty more new content to enjoy over the holidays, including an unlikely insight the... During four rounds of voting cardinals Jorge Mario Bergoglio of Argentina and Joseph Aloisius Ratzinger of Germany came... Seen in the late 1990s, nine men publicly accused Maciel of sexual abuse and formal... “ the Two Popes is certainly an acting showcase, but we made! Didn ’ t gotten great reviews, either. ) clearly no document of is the two popes accurate record member of the shoes!
Stephen West Yarn Along, Credit Saint Llc, The Mansard Roof, Jackson And Alex Lego Masters Final Build, Al Martino Height,